Rules or materiality: the oldest argument in securities regulation returns
The SEC's 2026 proposals replace line items with judgment. The argument between prescriptive rules and a materiality standard is as old as the…
The SEC’s 2026 agenda has a common thread. The executive compensation proposal, the semiannual reporting proposal and the filer status proposal each replace detailed requirements with fewer of them and leave more to the judgment of the company. The Commission calls the approach principles-based. The argument over it is as old as the securities laws.
1933: disclosure in place of merit
When Congress wrote the Securities Act it had two models. Many states regulated offerings on their merits: an official decided whether a security was sound enough to be sold. The federal statute took the other path. The government would not judge the investment. It would require the seller to tell the truth about it and would impose liability for failing to.
The idea is usually credited to Louis Brandeis, who had argued two decades earlier that publicity is a remedy for social and industrial ills. The Act’s Schedule A listed the items a registration statement had to contain. That list was the first set of line items.
Line items grow
For forty years the forms multiplied. Each type of offering and each type of report had its own, with overlapping and inconsistent requirements. In 1977 the SEC adopted Regulation S-K as a single source of non-financial disclosure requirements, and in 1982 it completed the integrated disclosure system, under which a company’s periodic reports and its registration statements draw on the same rules.
The principle of materiality developed alongside. In 1976 the Supreme Court held in TSC Industries v. Northway that a fact is material if there is a substantial likelihood that a reasonable shareholder would consider it important. That standard governs liability. The line items tell a company what it must address whether or not it thinks the answer is material.
Congress adds requirements
The two largest additions came from statute. Sarbanes-Oxley in 2002 required officer certifications and management and auditor reports on internal control. Dodd-Frank in 2010 required say-on-pay votes, the pay ratio, pay versus performance and several disclosures with social purposes.
Each responded to a failure. Each also added cost that did not scale down with the size of the company.
The turn toward scaling
The response was to scale by size. The smaller reporting company category arrived in 2008. The JOBS Act in 2012 created the emerging growth company with a five-year period of reduced requirements. The FAST Act in 2015 directed the SEC to simplify Regulation S-K, and in 2020 the Commission rewrote the business, legal proceedings and risk factor items along more principles-based lines.
2026
The current proposals go further in the same direction. Named executive officers would fall from five to two. Quarterly reports would become optional. About four-fifths of public companies would report on a scaled basis, and the threshold for the full regime would rise to $2 billion of public float.
The case for principles
The argument for a principles-based system is that line items produce volume. A company answers every item whether or not the answer matters, and the investor has to find what is important among pages that are there because a rule required them. A materiality standard asks the company to say what matters and to be liable if it leaves something out.
The second argument is cost. Fixed disclosure costs fall most heavily on the smallest companies.
The case for rules
The argument against is comparability. A line item produces the same data point from every company, which is what allows an investor to compare one with another. When each company decides what is material, the disclosures differ and the comparison is lost.
The second argument is enforcement. It is easier to show that a company omitted a required table than to show that an omitted fact was material. A system that relies on materiality relies on litigation and enforcement after the fact, and both are slower than a rule.
What this means for an issuer
A principles-based rule gives the company the decision and the responsibility together. Under a line item, counsel can check a draft against a list. Under a materiality standard, someone has to decide what a reasonable investor would want to know and record why. For a small company with little legal staff that is harder to do well, even though there is less to file.
The liability provisions are unchanged by any of the 2026 proposals. Section 11, Section 12 and Rule 10b-5 apply to what is said and to material omissions exactly as before.
Sponsor’s view
From Andy Altahawi, Adamson Brothers Corp., the sponsor of this publication. I welcome the lighter rules for small issuers and I support most of what the Commission has proposed this year. I also tell clients that a shorter form calls for more judgment than a long one. When the rule says disclose what is material, the company owns that judgment, and the plaintiff’s lawyer will test it with hindsight. Fewer line items is a saving in cost. It gives no protection against a claim.
Prepared with AI assistance from the filings cited in the margin and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.