FylaDigest
Daily roundup of new S-1, F-1, Form 10, 1-A and 8-K filings
Latest card filed Nov 21, 2026

Fyla Digest / Filing index

Filing

Section 404(b) after the filer status proposal: four cuts in 24 years

The SEC's May 2026 proposal would limit the Section 404(b) auditor attestation to companies with $2 billion of public float. How the requirement got here.

Nov 21, 20264 min read

The Sarbanes-Oxley Act was signed on 30 July 2002. Its most expensive provision, the auditor’s attestation on internal control over financial reporting under Section 404(b), has been cut back three times since. On 19 May 2026 the SEC proposed a fourth cut, and it is the largest: only companies with a public float of $2 billion or more would still need the attestation.

What the 2002 Act required

Congress passed the Act after the failures of Enron and WorldCom. Three provisions changed daily life at a public company. Section 302 made the chief executive and chief financial officer certify each periodic report personally. Section 404(a) made management assess the company’s internal controls every year and report the result. Section 404(b) made the outside auditor examine those controls and give its own opinion on them. The Act also created the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board to inspect the auditors.

The first two provisions cost management time. The third cost money, because it roughly added a second audit to the first. For a large company the fee was absorbed. For a small one it could exceed the cost of the financial statement audit itself.

Three rounds of relief

Smaller companies were given extra time to comply, and the deadline was extended repeatedly until Congress made the relief permanent. The Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 exempted non-accelerated filers, generally companies with a public float under $75 million, from Section 404(b). The JOBS Act of 2012 exempted emerging growth companies for up to five years after their IPO. In 2020 the SEC changed the accelerated filer definition so that a company with annual revenue under $100 million and a float under $700 million was also outside the requirement.

In each case management’s own assessment under Section 404(a) stayed in place, and so did the officer certifications. Only the auditor’s separate opinion was removed.

What the 2026 proposal would do

The May 2026 proposal replaces the five overlapping filer categories with two: large accelerated filers and non-accelerated filers. The large accelerated filer threshold would rise from $700 million of public float to $2 billion, a company would have to meet it for two consecutive years, and no company would be a large accelerated filer until it had reported under the Exchange Act for 60 months. Section 404(b) would apply to large accelerated filers only.

The SEC’s fact sheet estimates that about 19% of current public companies would be large accelerated filers under the new test. The other four-fifths would report without an auditor’s opinion on their controls. For a company planning an IPO, the practical effect is a five-year runway before the attestation can apply at all, whatever its size.

The argument on each side

Supporters of the change point to the cost. The attestation is a fixed expense that falls hardest on companies with the least revenue, and it is one of the items founders name when they explain why they stay private. They also note that management’s assessment and the officer certifications remain, so the company is still responsible for its controls.

Opponents point to restatements. The purpose of the outside opinion is to find control weaknesses before they produce a misstatement, and a company that assesses its own controls has an obvious reason to be generous. Commenters on the proposal have asked whether the exemption should reach every non-accelerated filer or stop at a lower float. A company with $1.5 billion of public float is not a small business by any ordinary measure.

What boards should do now

The proposal is not a final rule, and the comment file shows real disagreement about the $2 billion line. A company that expects to fall out of the requirement should still decide what it will do in place of the audit. Lenders, underwriters and acquirers will continue to ask about controls in diligence, and directors remain exposed if a weakness that the old process would have caught turns into a restatement.

Sponsor’s view

From Andy Altahawi, Adamson Brothers Corp., the sponsor of this publication. I advise boards of listed companies on governance, and I was running a broker-dealer when the Act came into force. My view is that the attestation was always priced for the wrong company. It was written with Enron in mind and then applied to issuers with thirty employees.

That said, removing the auditor does not remove the risk. I would tell an audit committee that leaves Section 404(b) to keep a written control review on its calendar every year and to have someone outside the finance department test it. The certification the chief executive signs has not changed, and it is signed personally.

Prepared with AI assistance from the filings cited in the margin and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.